Introducing....Insane Cookies!

As we all know 2020 has been a very challenging year for most of us.

Insane Cookies is how we are getting through it.

With our wedding cake business coming to a halt this year,

we had to pivot and come up with something to create to keep us moving.

This is how Insane Cookies was born!

Our cookies are baked from scratch and are unique because they are stuffed with lots of delicious goodness and have fun names.  We wanted to bring you something that would put a smile on your face. 

Trust us, you'll be hooked.

Scroll down to see the insanity!


The site will be open every Sunday from 9am-4pm EST.

All orders can be placed by filling out the form below.

Simply fill out your information and write out which ones and quantity.

*As of now, all orders are for local pickup only, but will soon have shipping as an option so you can send your friends and family some!

After Party

  This is a brown sugar base, mixed with tons of sprinkles and funfetti white chocolate chips, and stuffed with two Oreo cookies.  

Pudgy Boy

This is for all my peanut butter fanatics out there.  Brown sugar base, mixed with peanut butter chips and Reese's Pieces, stuffed with 2 white chocolate peanut butter cups and a gob of crunchy peanut butter.  Drooling yet?

Big Daddy

This is the cookie that started in all.  Brown sugar base, mixed with semi-sweet chocolate chips and mini M&Ms, stuffed with an Oreo, Reeses Peanut Butter Cup, chocolate nugget, and more M&Ms.  Holy sweet tooth.

Bobbin for Apples

This cookie,'s so good.  Cinnamon base stuffed with chunks of apples and gooey caramel.  We might keep this one year round, it's that good.

Campfire Nights

There's nothing like curling up next to a campfire and making s'mores. 
Chocolate base mixed with dark chocolate chips, stuffed with graham crackers and lots of gooey marshmallows. 

Circus Freak

Who doesn't love those frosted animal cookies?  This brown sugar base cookie is loaded with sprinkles and white chocolate chips and stuffed with animal cookies.  

Order Now!